Posted by Dogbuttface on March 27, 2001 at 16:27:29:209.108.11.67
In Reply to: I missed this one last time posted by HRG on March 26, 2001 at 18:49:08:
You are way out of your depth on this one, bub.
Hmm.. where to start...
First: My quoting the pop-culture icon Eminem (so
as to poke fun at YDSM) has nowhere near the
implications, in terms of "sell-out," as would
Deadbolt's choosing to "sell-out" to pop culture
via a cartoon adaptation of their act. If you
cannot see that very BASIC (yet crucial)
distinction, I hereby order you to sit in a quiet
little corner for a few hours and ponder it
closely- I'm confident it will come to you
eventually.
Second: So... my quoting Eminem's lyric somehow
excludes me from your priceless, twee
little "club" of integrity-correct punk-rock
blather? OK, according to you it may, but,
frankly, that's your narrrow little opinion. I
guess I'm honored, though, that you don't
consider me hip and cool. Says more about you
than me. By the way - YOU are SO cool, man.
Really!
Third: Please don't try to back-pedal on the
logic issue. You compared apples with baskeballs
initially (and got all hot-n-bothered in the
process).. I merely pointed that simple fact
out. You can accept it or not.
Fourth: There is NO fourth. (identify THAT
cryptic reference, smart ass!)
Fifth: I chose to ignore no "second, last and
pivotal) part of your message. And yes
(obviously), I responded to your response to my
response to you quoting me about my response to
your quote of the new Eminem cartoon. What else
could I do??!!
PS: Circular reasoning and the Ad Hoc fallacy are
things to be avoided, not pursued. You have been
warned!!
: You assumed that if Deadbolt lent their ideas
to
: a cartoon... no matter what that was, as if ANY
: of the DB ideas COULD EVER translate to
anything
: more than a 4 minute short w/ the Sick and
: Twisted FF... they would be selling out.
: Fine.
: You then go on to show just HOW MUCH punk rock
: integrity you have by quoting Eminem.
: Obviously you too have fell victim
: to "mainstream" baloney and I was calling you
out
: on that fact.
: Hey, I can quote Eminem too... but I ain't the
: one giving lashes with the studded belt of self-
: righteous anti-establishment.
: Speaking of non-logic... your response to me
was
: actually a response to me quoting you... not to
: mention my statement was entirely pivotal on
the
: second and last line... which was the part you
: chose to ignore.
: -HRG